Cinemalogy

Looking for MOVIE QUIZZES ? Download for FREE Cinemalogy

Schindler's List: A historical Check



Schindler's List is one of the Hollywood's best movies on Holocaust and the life of Jewish people in Nazi concentration camps. The movie is very well made and well detailed by Hollywood genius Steven Spielberg. Movie tells us the story of Oskar Schindler, a German businessman and a member of the Nazi party who established a factory in Nazi occupied Poland and hires Jewish labours. Unlike other Nazis, he is quite sympathetic with the Jews and consequently his factory becomes a heaven for the Jews living in concentration camps. Schindler gradually becomes attached to his Jewish workers and when the Jewish labours were to be transferred to other camp, he bought about 1000 labours using all his money save them from being gassed or killed ruthlessly. Schindler finally becomes bankrupt and died penniless after the war was over. He was declared a "righteous person" in 1963 by the state of Israel for rescuing Jews from Nazi atrocities.

The aim of this article is to examine the historical authenticity of what was shown in the movie and whether or not the movie is a part of Zionist propaganda to serve the Zionist cause of establishing the state of Israel over Palestinian land. In short we will see whether or not it is a propaganda movie. Let me make it clear that I am neither Holocaust denier nor a believer in the official story. Zionist consider it anti Semitic to question the Holocaust story and even have a law in Israel against it but I believe it is my right to remain sceptic about what actually happened in Nazi Germany and to question the official story. This article in no way is sympathetic towards the Nazi ideology. In fact, I strongly believe that the Nazis were racists and fascists. Nazism must be condemned and only a fascist can glorify them. But this article is aimed at examining the claim of Zionist propagandists so that the atrocities of the Nazis may not be used to serve the Zionist cause.



Now, coming back to the topic, as I said earlier it is one of the most well made movies on the topic of holocaust. Steven Spielberg is a genius film maker and can very cleverly convince his audience to believe whatever he shows them and that is why his movies usually turn into cult. Spielberg has a cult following and he has used his popularity and talent in many movies. His Jurassic Park had people believing into that dinosaurs can be resurrected using DNA. His portrayal of dinosaurs and their behaviour made more impact on people's mind than any National Geographic documentary. Similarly, his ET became a cult and common people started discussing the possibility of the existence of extra terrestrial life. Two things are very clear- first that most of the people are very naive in their approach to cinema and understanding its relevance to reality and second, Spielberg is very clever in exploiting this naive character of viewers to feed their minds anything he wants. What he has tried to feed people in Schindler's List is that every thing in the "official story" rather the "Zionist story" of the holocaust is an undeniable fact. He shows Jews being lined up for being gassed in concentration camps, naked men and women running around being humiliated, Jews being killed or tortured by ruthless Nazi officials for no reasons.

Schindler's List is based on a novel(which in itself is a work of fiction) titled in its first edition as "Schindler's Ark" written by Australian writer Thomas Keneally. This makes it very clear that the details of concentration camps shown in the movie are not historical facts but inspired from a fictitious work. Keneally's book itself has lots of errors and contradictions. For example, it says Heinrich Himmler was willing to promise the allies that the gassing of jews would stop but in reality Himmler never accepted that Jews were being gassed but instead called it an Allied Propaganda. Furthermore, Spielberg in his movie hides many facts mentioned in the book which is embarrassing for the Zionists. The book says that Oskar Schindler worked for a Hungarian Jew Rudolph Kastner but he is nowhere mentioned in the movie because Kastner helped in deporting hundreds of thousands of Jews to Auschwitz in return for favourable treatments of his Zionist comrades. Spielberg completely hides the high level cooperation between Zionists and the Nazis in his pro Zionist movie. Furthermore, the movie also hides the facts about the attitude of the National Socialist government towards the concentration camp. There were multiple orders from the government that the inmates in the camp were not to be brutalized and lots of enquiries were set up to investigate the violation of these orders. In fact, Amon Goeth who is the main antagonist of Spielberg's movie was arrested and imprisoned in 1944 by the Central Office of SS Judiciary on the charges of theft and murder of inmates of the camp. This fact was completely hidden in the movie and only a small "book audit" of Goeth administration was mentioned in one of the scenes which went completely unnoticed. Spielberg also ignored the role of the Jewish Ghetto police who worked for the Nazis. They are shown in the movie only as crowd controllers when in reality they were ruthless killers. In the end, Oskar is presented a golden ring by his Jewish workers which is inscribed with a verse from Talmud which says "whoever saves one life, saves the world entire". Here, Spielberg has also distorted Jewish literature. The actual verse from the Talmud says "Whoever saves a single soul of Israel, scripture ascribes to him as if he had preserved the entire world". The Talmud only talks about saving Jews and the verse is implying Jewish supremacy, a key concept of Zionist ideology. With the distortion of Jewish literature this great illusionist of Hollywood has surpassed all levels of deception and propaganda.

It is now very clear that Schindler's List is not  based on authentic history but it is more a hoax created by Steven Spielberg and a historical fraud. Spielberg, hiding all anti Zionist elements of the history and exploiting people's emotions, very easily convinced people that every detail of the movie is authentic history even though he never claimed it. Thus, Schindler's List is one of the best pro Zionist propaganda movie made in Hollywood ever which made people believe everything that Spielberg and his Zionist banker friends want. 

No comments:

Post a Comment